The Red Mill Inn Pizza - Brookfield

Very tasty. It was fine faster than they said so it was a little on the cool side.

We chose the Red Mill Inn because it was the evening before Easter and we had a party of 15 people and this was one of the few places that wasn’t booked.The one upside was that we actually got our own corner room because it was the only place where they could guarantee the entire party could eat together.Unfortunately, that’s where the good things end. The service was horribly slow… Not because they were that busy… It’s because our male server was not particularly competent. Case in point, we placed an order for some appetizers… Which are generally pretty quick and simple foods to prepare… And after waiting over half an hour, we had to hunt down the server and ask him where our appetizers were.By the time dinner came, there were a wide variety of orders ranging from steak for a couple people… Two pizzas for a couple others… To chicken Alfredo… A grilled salmon.Out of our 15 guests, I would say that 50 to 60% of them when asked how their food was said “it was OK”… Which is not praise as the dishes were on the pricey side such as $20 for salmon… $24 for a small steak, etc.As an overall summary, I would say that for the price you’re paying… You can certainly do better.For example, the food at Texas Roadhouse is far superior… And costs less as a whole although you can certainly get into the mid $20 range for a bigger steak. We would’ve gone there, but they do not accept reservations… And absolutely will not guarantee that a party of 15 can sit anywhere near each other. Best wishes wishes wherever you choose to go!l

We stopped in to have their fish dinner. I had half baked/fried cod and my wife had all baked cod. We both really enjoyed the fish, the fried cod was excellent. We also had the potato pancakes, which had a slightly sweet taste and were also really good. It’s an older establishment and look every bit of that statement. Our table and seats were clean and so was the rest of the seating area. I’d recommend trying their fish dinners and plan to go back. I thought it was a bit pricey compared with other restaurants offering fish fry dinners.

Odered the small Magnifica pizza. Very thin crust but soggy in the middle. Hardly any toppings for $24. Also left lots of grease on the plates. it was a terrible pizza.Waiter was great, very attentive.

Great restaurant with great service and delicious food. Their gluten free pizza crust is the best! It is made in house. Soooo gooood. Dietary restrictions: gluten free options that are delicious