Renzo's - East Islip

Stopped in here for lunch as I packed out Pat’s Marketplace next door afterwords. Amazing spot. Love the pizza and fair prices!

Owners were nasty acted like they didn't need your business good pie but I'm not going

Been eating here since I was a kid and the pizza has never changed. The pin wheels, the cheese steak, the garlic knots, the Vanilla Coke. Renzos is delicious and it’s a neighborhood staple for the East Islip area. I recommended the Buffalo slice, the chicken bacon ranch slice and the classic pepperoni. Spinach pinwheels are stuffed with spinach and cheese. Soo good!!

We have tried every Italian place in The Islip area and this place is by far the best!!! The pizza, meals, and sauce are amazing!!! Old school Italian!!!! Fantastic!!!!Very nice people as well!!!

The owners have changed but they have maintained their quality. Sauce and mozzarella were great. Pizza was not floppy and had a strong undercarriage. Their garlic knots were the showstopper! Very garlicy with a hint of parmesan and butter. Delicious!