Isola - EDGARTOWN

Fantastic food great appetizers and the service was fast and very efficient. Loved the specials and this is no ordinary Italian restaurant. Don't miss it if you are in Edgartown

Great place to bring young WELL BEHAVED children for an early res.(Figure late diners do not want to have kids around) . Staff attentive to food (nut) allergies. EVeryone very pleasant. A restaurant has been in that spot for a long time and it is as good as it has ever been. Dishes were surprisingly inventive without being precious. It is open all year round which is a big plus especially since food is so good

This was a dining experience, we had 14 different plates and they were all exceptional , this was not at all traditional Italian it had an unmistakable flair! The service was friendly and we were not at all rushed, just what the doctor ordered. Great Wine selection as well!

The restaurant location is perfect, a few blocks away from the Main Street/ The best time to have dinner about 6:30-7:00 because after dinner you can enjoy dancing in a few bars on Main street. Our waitress Sarah was extremely friendly and made us feel special. The lobster gnocchi was outstanding and it was very convenient that you can order half size portions and try a few different dishes. Also, we were amazed by Chef's Jimmy creativity for his daily specials. We tried smoked tuna's special and we amazed by the food presentation and the taste of the food. I highly recommend Tiramisu and Plum sorbet for dessert. Great place for celebrations and for enjoying great food. Good place for a bottle of wine and romantic dinner, very reasonable price for drinks. Can't wait to come back!!!!

The restaurant is a charming and fairly quiet spot. The service was pleasant and fairly efficient. The food was ok- not great. Ordered a yellowfin tuna over pasta special which didn't have much flavor and was drowning in oil. Other dishes ordered at our table were just ok- nobody was raving as far as I can remember. maybe worth another try- not sure.