New York Pizza Garden - Fishers

This place has a wide selection of menu options. I liked the fried catfish, although it was too salty. The wings come with the sauce on the side. The buffalo sauce is very spicy, so be careful. Maybe we just want to do it first. I didn't try the pizza, but the kids enjoyed it.

That was my first time here. I ordered the chicken sawarma with frits and absolutely loved every bite. The food was cooked to order and full taste. The staff was super polite and fast with their work. I'm coming back! 10/10 would recommend to anyone who wants some delicious food!

Tried this place for the first time and it won't be our last. The pizza was very flavorful and definitely one of the better ones in town. We also ordered wings and they were excellent!

I absolutely love the food at New York Pizza Garden! The chicken is so tender and cooked to order, tailored just the way you like it. Ameer, the server, was incredibly patient and kind while we placed our order; he's truly a wonderful person!

I ordered the family meal, which included two extra-large pizzas, 15 wings, and fries while I was in Indianapolis with my family. It was absolutely delicious! I nearly placed the same order again the next day to take home with me.