Papa Johns Pizza - Ithaca

Place was crazy, people were nice... Eating was Papa John's quality. Use the app and order ahead; work well.

Once again another Friday foods order at 9 am for a delivery for 1115 to borgwarner. Which is earlier then the lunch hour for any hiccups.. 20 mins late and no foor 45mins late no food... lunch is over people are back to work.... cause the scheduler doesn't put enough staff on the schedule during the busy time needed.. The poor girl answering the phone was so distraught and trying make it right i dont believe we were the only ones..i felt for her she was trying... the order refunded but a dozen people without lunch... pizza was dropped off at 1205 and those people will eat late at there next break 130....

Love Their Pizza! But an hour and a half to get to me? I would've just done pick-up if that's the case. Funny thing is I'm still waiting!!!

I specifically ordered a large pizza with sausage and black olives, but instead got sausage and MUSHROOMS! Seriously, I know the girl on the phone heard that, especially the last four digits of my phone number instead of what was on the box. Used to love PJ’s, but on a real note, you guys need to do a better job! And again, when I say BLACK OLIVES, I mean BLACK OLIVES! NOT mushrooms! Get it right!

I’ve never been this shocked from a food order. It’s almost like a sick joke. The refund from Doordash didn’t even justified the time I wasted. Truly unprecedented. I don’t even know how to criticize this. If there’s one thing you guys should avoid in life, it should be this papa johns store. Wth!