Nonna's Pizzeria Authentic Italian

The positives: the food is outstanding. Their sandwiches are simply amazing—the best chicken Parmesan I’ve had in all of Salt Lake City. While I find the pizza to be just average, I understand that it may appeal to others. On the downside: the management and misleading advertising are major issues. I attempted to place a large catering order (around $700-$800) a couple of weeks ago and called more than fifteen times on a Wednesday, but none of my calls were answered. Despite this, I decided to give them another shot due to the numerous positive reviews I’d heard about Nonna's. I’m glad I did, because the food was indeed fantastic.

This quirky little shop in Magna is a delightful surprise. I ordered the large salad, and it came loaded with a generous amount of toppings, along with the dressing on the side as I had requested. I also got a 16-inch pizza, half kitchen sink and half Hawaiian. The salad arrived first, giving me plenty of time to enjoy it before the pizza showed up. While I felt the pizza crust could have used a bit more cooking in the center, the flavors were fantastic. The prices were very reasonable, totaling less than $30 for both items. We even had half of the pizza left to take home as leftovers!

The pizza here is the best you'll find for miles! The garlic knots are delicious, and there's even a rumor that the place is haunted. If you're looking for authentic pizza on the west side, Nona's is definitely the spot. Their calzones are also fantastic. However, they occasionally close randomly for no clear reason, which can be quite frustrating and puzzling—maybe the hauntings have something to do with it! Regardless, the pizza is exceptional. Just a heads up: it's located near several bars, so it might not be the most family-friendly option at night. I recommend getting takeout instead.

Pizza was on point! Crispy crust on the bottom but chewy everywhere else. The butter dripping off of the garlic knots... come on! You could tell it was a family run business and I love that atmosphere!

This review has been LONG time coming... I had my WEDDING here back in October 2019. Nonna 's Pizzeria is owned, ran and managed by one of the best families I have ever met, who absolutely care about their customers and go above and beyond for their business. I was looking for a small east coast pub like venue for around 50 guests. Wanting to keep my wedding needs local I approached Nonna 's Pizzeria on Magna Main Street and they did not hesitate to say YES! I was so excited that they would facilitate to that particular need, and even more excited that I finally had an romantic venue just like I wanted that was in my price range. Sebastian and Tina made planning the food, seating and setting up for my wedding so easy and stress free for me, even though it was the 1st wedding they hosted they totally seemed like they knew exactly what they were doing. There was only one small hiccup with the sauces that we wanted for our chicken Parmesan. We asked all of our guests if they wanted white or red sauce and expressed that to Nonna 's before the wedding so they could plan on food. On the wedding day the food was being brought out and there was only red sauce. BUT, literally their red sauce is AMAZING, so I wasn 't disappointed. Then Sebastian and his family/team fixed the error IMMEDIATELY and even made my mom a special *Gluten Free* salad (that I spaced even telling them she needed with chicken and their awesome dressing that they make homemade. I am so impressed by this restaurants willingness to fix the issue and how fast they moved in the right direction after the error was noticed, most other places would have just said Oh Well, Too Late . I had people asking me if I was nervous to do my wedding at a place that had been on Ghost Adventures in fear or something happening during the ceremony and such, but it didn 't feel dark or gloomy or creepy, it just felt like a building filled with lots of love, and honestly what isn 't haunted in Magna ; . It was a day of CELEBRATION and everyone was cheerful, nice and welcoming. Made possible by Nonna 's and their great hospitality, great food and great vibes! My family and I will visit Nonna 's often for as long as it is there. Being A Magna Local, I really notice how fast restaurants come and go but I KNOW Nonna 's will always be open and serving awesome food because these people just know their sh!t, and love what they do! The VanderWaal 's