Gator Jack's Of Rexburg

Good restaurant that’s within walking distance of campus!

Really yummy! Great sandwiches, many options, and I’ve never been there when it was super crowded so we were helped quickly. I truly miss the swamp interior! It used to be such a fun, unique setting but now the restaurant has lost a lot of its charm and personality which makes me sad. Also they used to give you a cookie with your order for free and I miss that too.

Great sandwich shop in Rexburg! We stopped here on our way to the Tetons, and both ordered a daily special (medium sandwich of the day, free fry, drink, and a soft serve dole whip ice cream! . Totally worth it. Next to lots of other places to eat as well.

I usually love this place, I 've had delivery and dine in from them before. Today, I ordered a BLT for delivery with a bunch of toppings and sauces, and all I got was a sad excuse for a BLT with just mayo and lettuce on it- and lettuce wasn 't even one of the many toppings I ordered.Hopefully this is just a one time thing because I usually love this place :

Had a meat ball hoagie. It was terrible. The bun was soggy and cold. The marinara sauce was dreadful tasted like cheap spaghetti sauce from a can. I am not impressed. Also the service was less than friendly. Costa Vida down the street is fantastic.