Crabby Amy's - Seaford

We both wanted clam strips, but after about twenty minutes, our waitress informed us they had run out. Disappointed, we decided to go with shrimp instead. However, she returned shortly after to say that the kitchen had actually made a mistake and they did have clams available. Hooray! Our day was saved! Feeling guilty about the mix-up with our order, our waitress generously comped our next round of drinks. The food was fresh and delicious! They also have large bottles of malt vinegar, which are perfect with the seafood and fries. Prices are reasonable for what you get, and they accept credit cards.

The hot lobster roll was fantastic, and the service was exceptional. Our waitress, Olivia, had a wonderful attitude and was incredibly attentive! We will definitely return!

The food was delicious! I did find a bug in my drink when it arrived, but the staff promptly replaced it and apologized. It’s somewhat understandable given the location by the water. The prices were a bit on the high side, but the food was fresh and the view was lovely. I would definitely recommend this place!

Crabby Amy's is a fabulous little place right on the water. It gives you a classic Long Island vibe. The food is served very fast and the waiters and waitresses are so kind. Their specialty is the seafood however I don't like seafood so I went with the chicken tenders.(very adventurous of me, I know) They were amazing and very filling. We also got fries for the table which were tasty. There are many tables right on the water however many of those don't have shaded areas so don't forget to wear sunscreen and a hat! Enjoy!

We were just there on Saturday night...we got our drinks and appetizers but waited an hour and a half before our waiter told us they ran out of the bread rolls for the lobster roll...totally unacceptable! When we approached the manager she said that they had just opened yesterday, but why let us wait that long?! Never again!