Old Mill Tavern

Great food, awesome live music, and friendly service!

Pete, a classical guitar player, makes his place extra special on Saturday mornings! And the Ybor City style Cuban sandwiches are excellent! ?

Ms. Christy was very kind and helpful best service overall good experience and atmosphere ?

Owners are great bartenders tak Ed good care of you and food is great. Too bad theh dont have one in my home town

Tried it again after our last not so pleasant experience because of recent posts on social speaking highly of the food. Ordered sampler. Looked really good internal temp on mozzarella sticks and fried mushrooms were fridge temp cold. Mentioned to waitress who was great and apologized though it was not her fault. Cook threw the whole basket back down and refried everything to the point the whole plate was over done and hard as rocks. 2/3 of us ordered wings and this time the sauces were correct and thankfully the chicken wasn't undercooked but it was dang sure over cooked. Extremely dry and tough. My girlfriend ordered sweet potatoes fries as her side. Cook screams over restaurant that they are out of sweet potatoes fries. They provided her with regular fries which were really good but still applied a two dollar up charge for the sweet potatoes fries. I spent over 100 bucks and we ate as a group probably a half plate Disappointed yet again.