Panico's Bistro - West Cape May

Great dinner...I had the Sunday Dinner which includes Meatball, sausage and roast pork with pasta and my wife had the shrimp, crab with garganelli...both dishes were excellent and we took enough leftovers for another meal!! BYOB too!!!

The food is great. It is rather loud in there or else i would have given the ambience a 5. They have the best octopus! 4 people all had a good meal. A salad and one appetizer came to 170$. It is a byob

Enjoyed our dinner at Panico's Bistro. Beautiful interior with high ceilings and windows. Loved the color scheme and set-up of the room. Began with the Caesar Salad, which was good, but would have been better with less dressing. Our margherita pizza was tasty with a very crispy crust, delicious sauce and fresh basil. I wish they would have waited until we were finished with our salads before serving the pizza. Next time, I'll request they don't put the order in right away, so we could have more time to enjoy the bread, salad and wine beforehand. The table near us ordered some pasta dishes which looked yummy! All in all, a good dinner with attentive service and relaxing ambiance.

Our dining experience at Panico's was wonderful. The meatballs were the best I've had, the pasta sauce was very flavorful and the eggplant pesto entree was excellent. The menu was varied to please all diners.

Excellent food, generous portions, reasonable prices. While not training to be a “five star,” as others in the high price range in Cape May, it's at the top of its field at what it does. Great food, creative, good service, interesting ambiance in a converted church. And the staff definitely knows what they are doing and are friendly.