Papa Johns Pizza - South Plainfield

You see, I’ve been a pizza lover for a long time, but never have I ever eaten food this bad. When I ordered, I had mentioned to the staff up front that I wanted my pizza clean cut and well done. When I received my order, it was in fact not well done. When I asked for plates and seasonings, the staff seemed very displeased with my request and after a long sigh handed me 2 special seasoning packets for 2 medium pizzas. When I was about to ask for more, the employee quickly went to the back and didn’t come out. After getting home, I heated it up and to my surprise, there was basically no sauce and no cheese. Ob top of that the cheese tastes weird, and the crust is very white. This might have been the worst pizza ever. It’s so bad I had to leave this review so that others stay away from this location, as it is not living up to Papa John’s standards.

Order buffalo chicken pizza and they added pork so we all got sick ?

I only get this because my daughter likes it but I will never go to this store again. For months when I picked up my order I would ask for plates and they would say they didn't have any. today I went and asked for plates for my extra large pie and one guy goes to the back. The guy in the front asked how many plates I wanted. I said 8 so he yells back 8. The guy comes back with 1 plate (for an extra large pie). The other guy says he wants 8 plates to which he responds we only give 1 plate for free and you have to pay for the other ones. so that is it for papa john on park avenue in south plainfield... I will never again go to this place. I don't know if this is under new management or not but the service has dropped drastically over the last few months.

Not sure what happened with this location if it was sold or what pizza is different not as good wings come with almost no sauce and what ever was in the wrapping spilled out and the cardboard box is Saturated in it. On top of the slow delivery I got a text saying it was on the way at 6:25 it got to me at 7:05 I leave a few blocks away 3min drive tops

Great Taste, and plenty of pepperoni, and tasty ? sauce yum yum